We Asked a Lash Tech With 5,000+ Clients to Test the Top 4 Magnetic Lashes — Here's What She Actually Recommends
Nicole Reeves in her Tampa studio. After 6 years and 5,000+ extension clients, she now exclusively recommends magnetic lashes — and her clients keep asking what brand she wears.
When we started researching magnetic lashes for this review, we kept running into the same problem: every "comparison" online is written by someone who's never actually worked with lashes professionally.
So we did something different. We reached out to Nicole Reeves, a licensed esthetician in Tampa, FL who spent six years as a full-time lash extension technician. Over 5,000 clients. Fully booked, six days a week.
We asked her if she'd test the four most popular magnetic lash brands and give us her honest, professional evaluation. She agreed — on one condition.
"I'll do it, but I'm going to tell you the truth. Even if it's uncomfortable."
What she told us surprised us. It started with a confession.
"My Clients Would Always Ask What Lashes I Wore"
"For years, my clients would sit in my chair and say, 'Your lashes are amazing — what do you use?'" Nicole told us during our first call. "And I'd smile and say, 'Same thing I'm putting on you.' But that wasn't the whole story."
What Nicole didn't tell her clients was that after four years of wearing her own extensions, her natural lashes were falling apart.
Nicole explained that the combination of years of adhesive exposure and the weight of extensions on her follicles had caused real damage. When perimenopause hit at 47, falling estrogen levels made it worse — her lash growth cycle shortened and her follicles weakened.
Then she developed a contact allergy to lash adhesive. The same glue she'd been using on clients for years suddenly made her eyelids swell and turn red for days. She tried every hypoallergenic formula on the market. None of them worked.
"I'm a lash professional and I couldn't even wear lashes anymore," she said. "That's when a friend sent me a pair of magnetic lashes. I was skeptical. I'd seen the cheap ones. But I tried them — and I haven't looked back."
Nicole shared this photo of her natural lashes after removing extensions. "This is what six years of extensions did."
That was over a year ago. Today, Nicole's clients still ask what lashes she wears. But now she tells them the truth.
The Test: 4 Brands, 30 Days, One Professional Opinion
We sent Nicole the four most popular magnetic lash brands on the market. She tested each pair for a minimum of 30 days, wearing them for 8+ hours per session across different conditions — humidity, workouts, long workdays, and one wedding.
She evaluated each brand across six criteria: application ease, hold strength, comfort, natural appearance, value per wear, and whether they work on damaged or thin lashes — a category most reviews ignore, but one that matters enormously to the women who need these most.
"Most reviewers are 25 with perfect lashes testing these for fun," Nicole told us. "I'm testing them as someone whose lashes were destroyed. That's a completely different experience."
Here are her rankings, starting with her #1 pick.
Meylora uses dual-magnet "sandwich" technology — two magnetic strips click together over your natural lashes. No glue, no liner, no chemicals. Includes applicator and multiple styles from natural to glam.
Nicole's Take
"This is the brand I personally wear every day. I've tried dozens of magnetic lashes over the past year and nothing else comes close. The hold is incredible — 12+ hours without shifting. The lash fibers actually taper like real hair, not plastic. And because there's zero glue and zero weight on your follicles, my natural lashes have been growing back since I switched. That alone makes them worth it."
Pros
- Best value by far — BOGO means 2 pairs for ~$33 total
- No glue AND no magnetic liner — truly chemical-free
- Sandwich magnet tech holds all day (12+ hours tested)
- 3-second application with included applicator
- Works on thin, sparse, or damaged natural lashes
- Safe for sensitive eyes — nothing touches your skin or lash line
- Reusable 60+ times with proper care
- 30-day money-back guarantee
Cons
- Slight learning curve for first-time users (2-3 tries)
- Online only — not available in stores
"The clear winner. Best hold, best value, no chemicals, and it works on damaged lashes. This is the one I tell every former client to buy."
Free shipping · 30-day money-back guarantee
Nicole demonstrating the sandwich magnet application. "Top strip above, bottom strip below — they click together in three seconds."
Now let's look at how the other brands compared — and why none of them could match Meylora's combination of performance, safety, and value.
Nicole's Take
"Wosado makes a genuinely good product. The lashes are lightweight, the eye-shape targeting is smart, and the hold is solid. If money were no object, these would be a strong choice. But at $50–$70 per pair with no bundle pricing, I can't recommend them over Meylora when you're getting comparable results for less than half the price."
Pros
- Patented R-SLM magnetic technology — good hold
- Eye-shape specific styles (hooded, monolid, almond)
- Lightweight — only 0.034g per lash
Cons
- Expensive — $49.90 on sale, $69.90 full price per pair
- No BOGO or bundle deals
- Magnets visible up close
Beautiful quality, but the premium pricing with no bundle options makes them hard to justify.
Nicole's Take
"Enjuvie's product is competent — the sandwich magnet concept works. But at $59 for a single pair with a 6-14 day wait for delivery, the value just isn't there. I also found the magnets don't hold as securely as Meylora's. And the customer service complaints I've seen online are concerning — multiple women saying they couldn't get refunds."
Pros
- No magnetic liner needed — sandwich magnet design
- Lightweight feel once applied
- Nice variety of styles
Cons
- Very expensive — $59 for a single pair kit
- Multiple customer service complaints online
- Magnets don't hold as securely
- Long shipping times (6-14 days)
Decent lashes, but overpriced for what you get. The customer service issues are a red flag.
Nicole's Take
"I tested Higu Clace because it's the top-selling magnetic lash on Amazon and I wanted to see if the budget option could compete. It can't. The magnets are noticeably weaker, the applicator feels like a toy, and the lashes shifted throughout the day. You might save $20 upfront, but you'll be replacing them in weeks."
Pros
- Cheapest option — under $15 per pair
- Amazon Prime shipping
Cons
- Flimsy build — magnets feel weak
- Lashes shift and don't sit right
- Cheap applicator that pinches
- Looks and feels cheap on the eyes
- Unknown materials — not safe for sensitive eyes
Cheap price, cheap experience. False economy when Meylora's BOGO gives you two quality pairs for ~$33.
Side-By-Side Comparison
| Feature | Meylora | Wosado | Enjuvie | Higu Clace |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price (per pair) | ~$16.50* | $49.90 | $59.00 | ~$12.99 |
| Glue/Liner? | None | None | None | None |
| Application | ~3 seconds | ~3 seconds | ~3 minutes | ~3 minutes |
| Hold Duration | 12+ hours | 8-10 hours | 5-8 hours | 2-4 hours |
| Works on Sparse Lashes? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Weak magnets |
| Reusable | 60+ times | 3-6 months | 300+ times | 10-15 times |
| Guarantee | 30 days | Varies | 30 days | Amazon only |
| Nicole's Rating | 9.5/10 | 7.2/10 | 5.8/10 | 4.2/10 |
*With BOGO offer — 2 pairs for ~$33 = ~$16.50 per pair
"Here's Who I Tell to Buy These"
We asked Nicole who she specifically recommends Meylora to. Her answer was immediate:
If extensions damaged your lashes — the magnets sandwich over whatever you have left. No pulling. No weight. And your natural lashes can finally start recovering.
If you developed a glue allergy — zero chemicals, zero adhesives, nothing touches your skin. Nicole says this is the single biggest reason her former clients switch.
If perimenopause or menopause thinned your lashes — these give you back what hormones took away, without adding any stress to already fragile follicles.
If you're just tired of the cost — $33 for two pairs that last 60+ wears each vs. $150-300/month for extensions. The math isn't close.
What Other Women Are Saying
Left: Damaged lashes after years of extensions. Right: With Meylora magnetic lashes — no glue, no chemicals.
Our Final Verdict
After watching Nicole test all four brands for over a month, the results were clear. Meylora outperformed every other brand in hold strength, natural appearance, and value — by a significant margin. The fact that it's also the only brand Nicole personally wears every day says everything.
Meylora is currently running a Buy 1, Get 1 Free promotion — 2 pairs for about $33 total, with free shipping and a 30-day money-back guarantee.
If you've been spending hundreds on extensions, struggling with glue allergies, or watching your lashes thin out and feeling helpless — this is the recommendation from someone who's been on both sides of the chair.
Ready to Try Nicole's #1 Pick?
Join 100,000+ women who switched to Meylora.
Get The BOGO Deal — 2 Pairs for ~$33 →30-day money-back guarantee — if you don't love them, send them back. No questions asked.
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. All products were independently tested by Nicole Reeves. Medical information sourced from the American Academy of Ophthalmology and HELLO! Magazine. This content is not a substitute for professional medical advice.